The First-tier Tribunal had concluded that the film LLPs (but not the Games’ LLP) were trading with a view to profit on the basis that the LLPs contributed 30% to the films’ budget to acquire a 30% share of the films’ distributable income. In a supplementary decision the FTT concluded, however, that the film LLPs could not claim loss relief for their 30% contribution because it was a capital expense.
The UT has now agreed with HMRC that the film LLPs (like the Games’ LLP) were not trading but were investing. Furthermore, in agreement with HMRC, the UT also concluded that none of the LLPs’ activities were conducted with a view to profit but were designed to realise losses for their members to ensure that members’ contributions were finance by the UK Exchequer through claims for loss relief.
Malcolm Gammie QC appeared as counsel for HMRC in both the FTT and UT, leading a team of 8 counsel including Oscar Schonfeld.
The full decision can be found here.
London One Essex Court
Temple London EC4Y 9AR
Tel +44 (0)20 7583 2000
Fax +44 (0)20 7583 0118
Singapore 28 Maxwell Road
#04-14 Maxwell Chambers Suites
Tel +65 6634 1363
Fax +65 6634 1370